Project Management Tools Comparison: My Switch to ClickUp

I stared at my project management setup three months ago and was frustrated. Tasks scattered across three different tools. Deadlines I kept missing because they were buried in a forgotten board or on a post-it note. The system I built six months ago wasn't working anymore. Not because it was bad. It just couldn't keep up with how my business had shifted. Started wondering if I needed something different. Something that would work with how my brain works and business operates now, not how I thought it would all work when I first started. It's not about finding the ideal project management tool. It's about documenting what broke in my system, why I made the switch, and what's working better now. I’m not claiming this new setup is special. It's not. I’m tracking the mess so I can see what's shifting.

When I Realized My Project Management System Was Breaking Down

Missed three client deadlines in two weeks. All because tasks were buried in boards I rarely checked. My wake-up call wasn't subtle.

My original system made sense for the business I thought I'd build. Mostly digital products, occasional client work. Reality turned out different. Mostly client work, few digital products. The system wasn't built for what my business became.

I started creating workarounds. Color-coding. Duplicate tasks in different places. Calendar reminders to check my boards. Post-it notes everywhere. All these fixes became more work than the system was saving me.

I stuck with it. For months longer than I should have. Couldn't let go after spending so many hours setting it up. Too many templates created. Convinced myself one more tweak would fix everything.

The tipping point came when a client asked about something I thought was complete. I’d marked it done in one tool but not in the other where the deliverable needed to happen. Embarrassing moment that finally made me admit I needed something different.

The Project Management Tools I Tried and Abandoned

Trello: Visual But Limited

Started with Trello. Simple boards worked when my business was small. As things grew, so did the number of boards. Soon spent more time navigating between boards than doing the work. The visual system that helped me see everything at first? Turned into chaos.

Asana: Team-Focused Overkill

Moved to Asana. Heard it was better for growing businesses. More robust features. That became the problem. Asana felt built for teams, not a solo business owner. Too many collaboration features I didn't need. After a month, I was avoiding opening it.

Notion: Beautiful But Overwhelming

Then Notion. Those beautiful templates promising to organize my entire business life. Spent hours setting up dashboards and linked databases. Never made it past week one. The blank canvas that seemed so flexible became overwhelming. Too many decisions about structure.

Monday.com: Powerful But Excessive

Tried Monday.com. Colorful. Intuitive. Way too powerful for what I needed. Like using a sledgehammer for a push pin. Most features built for team collaboration I simply didn't need.

My Current Project Management System That Works

I circled back to ClickUp. I tried it earlier but abandoned it for being too complex. This time, I approached it differently. Ignored most of what it offered. Cut the dashboards. Ditched the automations. Created a clean list view with basic status tags and deadlines.

My current setup is minimal. Three lists: Client Work, Business Admin, and Content Creation. Each task has a status tag and due date. That's it. No complicated workflows or complex dependencies. No intricate labeling system.

This basic setup matches how I work. I don't need to visualize complex project timelines, I need to know what's due this week. I don't need complex task dependencies, I need to see what's still open.

The unexpected benefit? Less stress when I open my project management tool. The visual simplicity means less mental load. No more feeling overwhelmed before I even start working. Just simple lists of what needs to be done.

My current ClickUp setup using simple lists and due dates to stay on track with client work and business tasks

The Transition Process: Moving From Old System to New

The transition wasn't clean or quick. I evaluated what was worth transferring. Realized most backlogged tasks weren't relevant anymore. Moved only active projects and tasks for the next two weeks.

Ran both systems simultaneously for two weeks. Added new tasks to both. Completed tasks in both. This double-entry was tedious but necessary. Needed to make sure the new system worked before abandoning the old one.

Surprised myself with how emotionally attached I was to the old system. Even though it wasn't working and causing stress. It was familiar. It was mine. Letting go felt like admitting failure somehow.

I made small tweaks during the first month. Added a priority flag for urgent tasks. Created a simple view for today's tasks only. Added a "Waiting" status for tasks needing input from others. These minor adjustments made a big difference.

It took longer than expected for the new system to feel natural. About six weeks. The first month was constant adjustment. Questioning if I'd made the right choice. By week six, checking my ClickUp lists became automatic, not a chore.

I’m still figuring out what works for my brain and my business. Not done tweaking this system. Don't think I'll ever be. My setup? ClickUp with most stuff turned off. Ran both old and new systems for two weeks before switching over. I continue to make changes when something stops working. That's normal though. Business changes and systems change too. I don't need the tool with all the bells and whistles. I need one that will work after my 9 to 5.

© 2025 Merissa Si-Lence. All rights reserved.